MSCC, Sharon Jasprizza, Oct 23, 2025

NOTE ABOUT THIS RECAP: This meeting recap, based on summaries generated by CHATGPT, has been revised for clarity and reformatted to adhere to the established style of MSCC, including edits and additional information that CHATGPT did not provide.  

SUMMARY

Rob Robinson, formerly homeless community organizer and activist based in New York City, Senior Advisor Partners for Dignity and Rights. https://youtu.be/MS2jy0Gli_g 

• The “right to shelter” in New York City, which ensures that anyone can access a bed, has created Rob refers to as a “shelter industrial complex.” This system, while better than the streets, often lacks the necessary social services and support to help individuals transition out of homelessness.
• The “Housing First” policy has been successful in places like Finland, Hennepin County in Minnesota, and Houston, Texas. This approach prioritizes providing housing first, followed by the necessary social services, recognizing that stable housing is a foundation for addressing other issues.

Kieth McHenry, Co-founder Homes Not Jails and contributed to the establishment of the Independent Media Center, both of which reflect his commitment to community organizing and social change. His work with the Food Not Bombs Free Skool in Taos, New Mexico.

• One of the key strategies employed by Food Not Bombs under Keith’s guidance was the occupation of abandoned buildings to provide shelter for the homeless.

CHAIR: John Mudd

MINUTES: Sharon Jasprizza

POLICY MEETING UPDATES

There were no policy meeting updates. 

AUGUST HIGHLIGHTS

August was an action-packed month for MSCC’s advocates for public housing. Plus, some late updates from earlier in the year we missed highlighting.

• https://manhattanplan.nyc/share-your-ideas/ to let NYC your ideas for housing. Don’t forget the best way to increase productivity is to house people. Take care of people, ensure people have healthcare and access to healthy food. We need to be the care economy not a profit driven one for the few. 
• MSCC opened Chelsea Public Housing Legal Defense Fund to save NYCHA housing. For updates on the fight to save Chelsea’s public housing, email midtownsouthcc@gmail.com to join the “Friends of the Chelsea Public Housing Coalition” email list.
• Two of our MSCC advocates appeared on NY1 on August 28th, Renee Keitt, President of  the Elliott-Chelsea Tenants Association and Layla Law-Gisiko, District Leader, discussed the demolition plan with Errol Louis on NY1 to talk about the truth behind the demolition plan for Chelsea’s public housing. You can listen to the clip here. 
• On August 25th, Renee Keitt, Layla Law-Gisiko, and Joe Maniscalco aired on WBAI’s Early Morning Moral Monday show. Their discussion highlights the fight against the demolition and land grab. At 36 minutes in listen to an incredible interview with Renee Keitt, Layla Law-Gisiko and Joe Maniscalco on Early Morning Monday’s Moral Monday show hosted by Bob Hennelly on WBAI.
• LEAPS Co-Chair Lizette Colón sent a compelling letter, which was published on September 1, 2024, in the Chelsea Community News. to elected officials regarding the demolition. This is a powerful letter to our electeds who “serve the interests of private entities seeking to appropriate Chelsea’s public housing,” rather than our communities.
• Leonard Polletta’s August article in the Village View– outlines the serious threat posed by private developers. “NYCHA’s bureaucracy has been responsible for allowing the conditions to deteriorate for years. This is true despite the fact that 500,000 New Yorkers currently live in public housing. Some say NYCHA leadership is in the pocket of the real estate industry.”
• Read Pam Wolff’s letter, published in the Chelsea News on August 8, 2025, to Erik Bottcher urging him to stop supporting NYCHA’s controversial plans. Stop Supporting NYCHA’s ‘Indefensible’ Plan for Chelsea.
• District Leader Layla Law-Gisiko’s detailed timeline of events leading to the current situation is in Layla Law-Gisiko’s chronicle of the timeline titled “Housing, Power, & Broken Promises: The Fight over NYCHA’s Chelsea Redevelopment”, August 2025.
• Joe Maniscalco’s Public Housing Tenants Push Back Against Privatization at Elliott-Chelsea & Fulton Houses was published in Work Bites on August 14, 2025
• And one we missed on April 23, 2025 is David Holowka’s NYCHA’s Chelsea Gold Mine. It is dynamite.
• And another we missed in July 2023 is the link to the YouTube replay and to the interactive 3D model of the FEIS alternatives. Layla Law-Gisiko’s speaks with urban planners George Janes and Alihan Polat who provide insights into the Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) for the proposed redevelopment of the Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea NYCHA campuses. 
• And in late May, 2025 Renee Keitt’s powerful testimony, President of the Elliott-Chelsea Tenant’s Association, is powerful advocacte for public housing preservation. Testimony here.

SPECIAL INTRODUCTION(S) AND OR UPDATES: 

• Emma Embleton, Midtown Community Court: offers alternatives to incarceration for misdemeanor charges. Provides social services, housing connections, food services, and addresses the root causes of offenses. Handles almost all misdemeanors except misdemeanor assault cases. No jails at the site. Mentions a leak in the backyard where MSCC runs the urban farm. Emma is working with the city to fix it.
• Renee Keitt, Tenants Association leader for Elliott Chelsea: Recently interviewed on Errol Lewis, discussing community issues. Critical of a letter from HHH and the FEIS, advocating against demolition and for better representation. Participating in the Labor Day Parade and the African American Day Parade with CECA, chanting “No Demolition.”
• Keith McHenry, Co-founder of Food Not Bombs: acknowledges the ongoing battle against developers and political systems.
• Charisma White, MSCC and community organizer: Hosting an information table and barbecue in Brooklyn to provide community resources. Sharing information on campaigns, food stamps, pantry food, laundry services, and soup kitchens.
• Cheri Leon, The Street Homeless Advocacy Project: Offers meals and safe haven placements for homeless individuals. Weekly outreach on West 32nd Street near Penn Station, serving hot meals and providing safe havens. Suggests having an advocacy table at the Communities Together event on September 21st. Makes reference to Marc Greenberg, Executive Director and co-founder of the Interfaith Assembly on Homelessness and Housing: addressing homelessness through advocating public policy solutions and other strategies in partnership with an ever-broadening network of faith communities, other advocates, housing and service providers, elected officials and those who have experienced homelessness. Provides weekly outreach near St. Francis of Assisi, providing hot meals.  
• Luana Green, MSCC: The Fulton Elliott Chelsea Coalition Against Demolition is participating in the Labor Day parade.

COMMUNITIES TOGETHER: SOCIAL JUSTICE AND MUSIC FEST

• John Mudd outlined the Communities Together: NY Social Justice & Music Fest. It is on Sunday, September 21, 2025, | 10 AM – 4 PM | 41st Street (between 6th & 7th Avenues), NYC.
• The Midtown South Community Council (MSCC) and coalition partners present Communities Together: NY Social Justice & Music Fest—a full-day festival of music, community, and action calling for equity, resilience, and justice in New York City.
• This year’s festival is a resounding “Enough is Enough” to: A healthcare system that profits over people. Development policies that displace long-term communities. Inequality that leaves New Yorkers struggling for mental, physical, and economic health. Social, economic, and foreign policies that is destroying societies here and abroad. Alongside urgent dialogue and coalition-building, the day will feature world music, hymns of resilience, songs of protest, and a unifying finale of hope and solidarity.
• The festival is a Call to Action: To foster a sustainable society through fair housing, healthcare, and equitable development. To reclaim the city from those who prioritize profit over people. To confront growing inequalities and demand investment in communities and infrastructure.
• Please see the CT Post Card here:
  https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qn-10gmG0s1YhXeVJqdXTuEMTJKmR2xg/view?usp=sharing
• People are invited to set up a table for their services, goods, and invited to perform their artistic skills. Please complete this participation form: https://communities-together.paperform.co.

CREATING, CRIMINALIZING POVERTY

Rob Robinson, formerly homeless community organizer and activist based in New York City, Senior Advisor Partners for Dignity and Rights

• Rob’s personal journey and advocacy efforts provide a profound perspective on the complexities of homelessness and housing insecurity in the United States. His experiences in Miami and New York City, where he spent two and a half years on the streets of Miami and 10 months in New York City homeless shelters, have shaped his understanding of the systemic issues at play. These experiences highlight the stark differences between cities in terms of resources and approaches to homelessness.
• In Miami, Rob faced the harsh reality of begging to eat and the dangerous impact of the sun on those living on the streets. He recalls the tragic story of Arkansas, a man who “thought himself to death in the sun,” illustrating the extreme conditions that can lead to death for those without shelter. The lack of resources in Miami, where there are only three shelters for a population of 2 million, contrasts sharply with New York City, which has nearly 600 shelters for 8 million people. This disparity underscores the unequal distribution of resources and the varying levels of support available to those experiencing homelessness.
• Rob’s time in New York City shelters also revealed the challenges of navigating a system that, while more robust, still falls short of providing adequate support. He emphasizes that even a 30-day stay in a shelter should be considered an emergency, and any longer is unacceptable. The “right to shelter” in New York City, which ensures that anyone can access a bed, has created Rob refers to as a “shelter industrial complex.” This system, while better than the streets, often lacks the necessary social services and support to help individuals transition out of homelessness.
• His advocacy work extends beyond personal experience, as he serves as a professor of urbanism at The New School and a senior advisor for Partners for Dignity and Rights. Robinson is also involved in a consulting group working with the Chicago Continuum of Care on a federal grant to move people from street homelessness directly into housing. This initiative aims to develop a process for making this transition, recognizing that simply providing housing is not enough without the necessary support services.
• Rob’s global perspective is further evident in his work with the Institute for Global Homelessness, where he contributes to efforts to universally count homelessness systematically across different countries. This international approach highlights the need for standardized data collection and a coordinated global response to homelessness.
• The current political climate, with proposals to cut HUD funding and criminalize homelessness, adds another layer of complexity to the issue. Rob criticizes the lack of empathy from the current administration, noting that cuts to benefits, vouchers, and HUD funding exacerbate the challenges faced by those living in impoverished situations. The proposed “sweeps” campaigns, which disperse encampments without providing alternative housing, further disrupt the sense of community and self-sufficiency that many homeless individuals rely on.
• Rob’s advocacy is not just about critiquing the system; it’s also about proposing solutions. He advocates for a “Housing First” policy, which has been successful in places like Finland, Hennepin County in Minnesota, and Houston, Texas. This approach prioritizes providing housing first, followed by the necessary social services, recognizing that stable housing is a foundation for addressing other issues.
• His experiences with the “Take Back the Land” movement and stories of successful squatting initiatives, such as those in New York City and Sao Paulo, Brazil, demonstrate the potential for creative solutions to housing crises. These examples show how communities can repossess vacant spaces and create cooperative living arrangements, providing a model for how housing can be reimagined.

DISCUSSION

• Luana Green highlights the criminalization of homelessness in Trenton, New Jersey, where the city is fining homeless individuals and, which often leads to incarceration due to their inability to pay the fines. This creates a cycle of recidivism and makes it difficult for individuals to secure housing or employment in the future. There is a prevalence of empty storefronts and businesses in the city. These vacant spaces could be converted into housing for those experiencing homelessness, addressing the contradiction between available space and the need for shelter.
• Rashida Tyler points out the contrast between poverty and wealth in New York City, where opulence exists just blocks away from areas with high concentrations of homeless individuals.
• Damyanti Radheshwar notes there is a lack of political commitment to addressing homelessness in New Jersey. She mentions her experience working on housing for the homeless in downtown Brooklyn and expresses frustration with the absence of meaningful political dialogue on the issue. There is a need to be a stronger political awareness and commitment to demand action on homeless housing, especially with the upcoming mayoral election.
• John Mudd notes there is a need for a more proactive approach to addressing homelessness, suggesting that the city should demand more from developers and public institutions in terms of providing affordable housing.
• Robert Robinson does not use the term affordable but says we need housing for people with incomes of $50,000 a year or less.

Keith McHenry, Co-founder Homes Not Jails and contributed to the establishment of the Independent Media Center, both of which reflect his commitment to community organizing and social change. His work with the Food Not Bombs Free Skool in Taos, New Mexico.

• Keith’s journey with Food Not Bombs is a testament to his lifelong commitment to social activism and community organizing. Born in Frankfurt, West Germany, in 1957, Keith’s early life was influenced by his father’s military service, which led the family to various locations, including the United States. This upbringing instilled in him a deep sense of global awareness and a passion for environmental and social justice.
• His activism began in earnest during his time at Boston University, where he became involved with the Clamshell Alliance, an anti-nuclear group. His experiences with this organization sparked a series of protests against nuclear power and war, laying the groundwork for the founding of Food Not Bombs. In 1980, Keith, along with several other anti-nuclear activists, established the first Food Not Bombs chapter in Cambridge, Massachusetts. The group’s initial focus was on providing food to those in need while simultaneously advocating against military spending and nuclear proliferation.
• The early days of Food Not Bombs were marked by creative and often theatrical forms of protest. Keith and his colleagues would dress up as hobos and hold “soup lines” outside of stockholders’ meetings and other symbolic locations to draw attention to the stark contrast between wealth and poverty. These actions were not only a form of street theater but also a means of engaging the public in discussions about social inequality and the misuse of resources.
• As the group evolved, it faced increasing challenges, particularly in the form of arrests and legal battles. In San Francisco, for instance, Food Not Bombs encountered significant resistance from local authorities who were reluctant to provide permits for their food-sharing activities. Despite these obstacles, the group continued to grow, with chapters springing up across the United States and eventually around the world. Keith’s leadership was instrumental in this expansion, as he traveled extensively to support the establishment of new chapters and to participate in global gatherings.
• One of the key strategies employed by Food Not Bombs under Keith’s guidance was the occupation of abandoned buildings to provide shelter for the homeless. This approach not only addressed the immediate need for housing but also highlighted the absurdity of having vacant properties while people were living on the streets. Keith’s ability to mobilize volunteers and coordinate these efforts was crucial to the success of this initiative.
• Keith’s influence extended beyond Food Not Bombs to other activist groups and initiatives. He co-founded Homes Not Jails and contributed to the establishment of the Independent Media Center, both of which reflect his commitment to community organizing and social change. His work with the Food Not Bombs Free Skool in Taos, New Mexico, further underscores his dedication to education and sustainable agriculture as tools for social transformation. FOOD NOT BOMBS FREE SKOOL NFP is a non-profit organization dedicated to education and social transformation. Its mission is to operate as a free school, teaching individuals about social change through accessible, community-driven programs that inspire action and foster equity. Operating as a non-profit under Sections 501(c)(3) and 170(b)(1)(A) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, we are committed to uplifting communities across Arizona and New Mexico by providing educational resources and opportunities. Our goal is to build strong community ties, increase awareness, and encourage participation through our programs, enriching the lives of those we serve and fostering a more equitable society. https://foodnotbombsfreeskool.org/
• In recent years, Keith has been vocal about a range of issues, including his skepticism of the official narrative surrounding the September 11 attacks and his stance on COVID-19 vaccinations. These positions have garnered both support and criticism, but they are consistent with his long-standing commitment to questioning authority and advocating for individual rights.
• Despite the challenges and controversies, Food Not Bombs continues to thrive under Keith’s leadership, with chapters active in over 1,500 locations worldwide. The organization’s three core principles—providing free food to anyone, maintaining a decentralized structure, and dedicating itself to nonviolent direct action—remain central to its mission. Keith’s vision of a world where resources are used to feed the hungry rather than fund war and destruction continues to inspire activists and communities around the globe.

DISCUSSION

• Caitlin Cahill notes the global and local dimensions of Food Not Bombs’ work, highlighting the organization’s impact in changing narratives around homelessness and criminalization. Seeks the best of way fighting back against the narrative that criminalizes homeless individuals, especially in the context of the militarization of Washington, and how can grassroots organizations challenge dominant narratives and advocate for policy changes that support vulnerable populations.
• John Mudd notes coalition building and public housing advocacy while working with various groups to address homelessness and housing inequality are essential. Its important to work with local and national politicians in addressing these issues and acknowledging the challenges of working with a representative government that often overlooks the needs of homeless individuals. 
• Robert Robinson is known for his work as a Professor of Urbanism at The New School and his advocacy through organizations like Picture the Homeless. He shares his insights on the importance of electoral engagement and the need to send strong messages to politicians to advocate for the rights of homeless individuals. Rob emphasizes that, despite his personal disdain for electoral politics, it is crucial for activists to get involved in the political process to effect change. He also discusses the power of outside money in influencing political outcomes and the need for organized resistance to corporate interests. Rob’s experience and expertise provide a critical perspective on the intersection of politics, advocacy, and community organizing in the fight against homelessness.
• Keith McHenry, the co-founder of Food Not Bombs is dedicated to addressing hunger and homelessness. His journey with Food Not Bombs began in the early 1980s, driven by a desire to challenge military spending and advocate for social justice. Keith’s work has taken him from Boston to San Francisco, where he has faced numerous challenges, including arrests and legal battles. He shares stories of occupying abandoned buildings to provide shelter and the creative strategies employed by Food Not Bombs to support homeless individuals. Keith’s insights highlight the importance of mutual aid and community building in addressing the dehumanization of homeless people. He also discusses the impact of gentrification and the role of local media in shaping public perception of homelessness. His global perspective, informed by experiences in Palestine and other conflict zones, adds to ways of building resilience and community in the face of fascism and totalitarianism.

SUMMARY OF CHAT BOX

Alex Yong: MSCC 

• MSCC’s farm summary video https://youtu.be/5lS86hJEiWE
• Midnight Run http://www.midnightrun.org
• “Beyond The Bridge” by Don Sawyer, a friend of Rob Robinson. emphasizing its focus on “Housing First” supportive housing.
• UN’s definition of homelessness and NYC’s definition of homelessness as not having a lease.
• Video update on hotels-to-residential conversion https://youtu.be/Z6v8UtfuHAk  

Robert Robinson: Partners for Dignity and Rights

• Shared a Bloomberg article on the rise and fall of the American SRO https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-02-22/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-american-sro
• Mentioned that he follows the United Nations’ definition of homelessness.
• Will reach out to Don Sawyer regarding the screening of “Beyond the Bridge” in NYC.

 Pete Diaz

• Noted that Webster’s New World Dictionary (2nd College Edition, 1970) does not define homelessness.

Luana Green: MSCC

• Announced a Town Hall on September 18th with Mamdani, mentioning the Chelsea Reform Democratic Club for more information.

Damyanti Radheshwar

• Mentioned Living Land CCA and the great work by the indigenous community.

Cheri Leon, The Street Homeless Advocacy Project  

• Email (chelewon@gmail.com) and the website for Street Homeless Advocacy Project is http://shapnyc.com.

NEXT Meeting Homeless and Housing Meeting: 9:30 AM Tuesday, October 7, 2025. Always the 1^st Tuesday of every month. Contact hello@midtownsouthcc.org or john.mudd@usa.net for more information and Zoom invitations.